Should you choose shingle or metal roofing for your home? This article breaks down the pros and cons of each option, considering cost, durability, and energy efficiency, including a detailed look at shingle vs metal roofing pros and cons.
Key Takeaways
- Metal roofing has a higher initial cost but offers long-term savings through reduced maintenance and energy bills, making it a financially beneficial choice for homeowners.
- While asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront, their lifespan is significantly shorter than that of metal roofing, which can last 40 to 80 years with minimal upkeep.
- Metal roofs are more energy efficient and environmentally friendly than asphalt shingles, reflecting solar energy and utilising recycled materials, leading to less waste and pollution.
Comparing Costs: Metal Roofing vs. Shingle Roofing
When it comes to cost, asphalt shingles are known for their lower initial expense, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. The average price for a mid-range shingle roof is around $8,700, while installing a metal roof can set you back significantly more, averaging about $17,400 or higher. The metal roof cost difference is evident, with metal roofing materials generally falling in the range of $5,000 to $13,000 for initial costs, while shingle roofing tends to be more affordable upfront.
However, it’s essential to consider the long-term financial implications. Metal roofs, despite their higher initial cost, often lead to savings in maintenance and energy bills. Additionally, homeowners may receive insurance discounts for having a metal roof due to its durability and lower likelihood of damage.
While the return on investment for a new metal roof averages around 60.9%, shingle roofs may require more frequent replacements over time, potentially costing thousands more.
Durability and Lifespan of Metal Roofs and Shingle Roofs
Durability and lifespan are critical factors when choosing roofing materials. Metal roofs generally boast an impressive lifespan of 40 to 70 years, with some lasting up to 80 years depending on the material and installation quality. This exceptional durability is due to the strength of metal panels, which require minimal maintenance and are less susceptible to damage.
On the other hand, asphalt shingle roofs typically last about 15 to 30 years, depending on various factors such as climate, installation, and maintenance. Asphalt shingles are more prone to issues like pooling water and temperature fluctuations, which can significantly reduce their lifespan.
Therefore, while shingle roofs may be more affordable initially, metal roofs offer a longer-lasting and more durable solution, reducing the need for frequent roof replacements.
Energy Efficiency: Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles
Energy efficiency is another crucial consideration for homeowners. Metal roofs are known for their excellent reflective properties, capable of reflecting up to 70% of solar panels energy. This high reflectivity can lead to significant energy savings, particularly in warmer climates where metal roofs can reduce cooling costs by reflecting solar heat. In fact, metal roofs energy efficient can result in potential savings of about 50% on energy costs.
Conversely, asphalt shingle roofs are less efficient in this regard. Dark asphalt shingles typically absorb and release heat into the home, raising indoor temperatures by 20 to 25 degrees. With a reflectivity of only around 22%, asphalt shingles are less effective at reducing energy consumption compared to metal roofs.
Thus, for homeowners looking to enhance their home’s energy efficiency, metal roofing presents a more advantageous option.
Environmental Impact of Metal and Shingle Roofs
The environmental impact of roofing materials is increasingly important for eco-conscious homeowners.
Metal roofs stand out in this regard, as they consist of:
- 35–95% recycled materials
- A production process that consumes significantly fewer resources compared to asphalt shingles
- The use of recycled materials that helps reduce the demand for new raw materials.
In contrast, asphalt shingle production often leads to air and water pollution due to resource extraction and processing. Additionally, over 12 million tons of asphalt shingles end up in landfills annually, contributing significantly to waste generation.
The long lifespan of metal roofs further reduces the volume of waste sent to landfills compared to shingle roofs. Overall, metal roofs are considered more eco-friendly, making them a better choice for those concerned about their environmental footprint.
Aesthetic Appeal and Design Options
Aesthetic appeal and design options are essential considerations for homeowners looking to enhance their property’s curb appeal. Metal roofing offers a wide variety of styles and colours, including designs that mimic traditional roofing materials like slate, tile, and wood shakes. This versatility allows homeowners to choose a metal roof that complements their home’s architectural style and personal preferences.
Shingle roofs also provide extensive design options, with styles that mimic slate, wood shakes, and tiles, and a broad colour palette to choose from. When selecting roofing colours, it’s crucial to consider the architectural shingles style of the home, neighbourhood aesthetics, and potential HOA regulations to ensure visual harmony.
Earthy tones and warm shades are often preferred in rural areas, while distinctive finishes like copper and bronze can add character and elegance to a home over time.
Weather Resistance: How Metal and Shingle Roofs Perform
Weather resistance is a vital factor, especially in areas prone to extreme weather conditions. Metal roofing is incredibly resilient, capable of withstanding high winds up to 140 miles per hour, making it suitable for hurricane-prone areas. Metal roofs are also non-flammable and typically have a Class A fire rating, the highest available, reducing the risk of fire during wildfires or lightning strikes.
Asphalt shingle roofs, while durable, are generally more susceptible to damage from severe weather conditions. Large hail can cause significant damage to shingles, and they are less effective at resisting high winds compared to metal roofs and asphalt roof. Additionally, asphalt shingle roofing can be less resilient in extreme conditions.
Although metal roofs can dent from hail impacts, the damage is usually cosmetic rather than structural. In terms of weather resistance, metal roofs dent offer superior protection and durability, ensuring consistent performance throughout their lifespan.
Installation Process and Labour Considerations
The installation process and labour considerations are essential when planning a roofing project. Installing a metal roof is generally more complex than shingle roofing due to the specialised techniques and equipment required. This complexity necessitates hiring skilled and specialised tradespersons, which can increase labour costs. Labour expenses for metal roofing installation typically range from $5 to $12 per square foot, higher than those for shingle roofing.
On the other hand, shingle installation is more straightforward and can be completed with minimal specialised skills and tools. Despite this, consulting with a professional roofing contractor is crucial for both types of roofing to ensure they are installed properly and maximise their longevity and performance.
While the initial cost of metal roofing installation may be higher, the long-term benefits can outweigh the upfront expenses.
Maintenance and Repair Needs
Maintenance and repair needs are critical considerations for the long-term management of your roof. Metal roofs are known for their low maintenance requirements, contributing to their long-term durability and cost savings. They generally require less maintenance compared to asphalt shingles, which can develop issues like cracking, curling, and mold growth, necessitating regular upkeep.
However, repairing metal roofs can be more complex and costly than repairing asphalt shingles. While metal roofs are resistant to mold and algae, they still need periodic inspections for dents, scratches, and rust.
Overall, metal roofs offer a low-maintenance solution, but the potential complexity and cost of repairs should be considered when making a decision.
Noise Levels: What to Expect from Metal and Shingle Roofs
Noise levels during rainstorms or hail can be a concern for homeowners. Metal roofs can vary in noise levels depending on the type and installation method. During a rainstorm, metal roofs generate sound levels around 52 dBA, comparable to the 46 dBA of asphalt shingles. Thicker panels and specific installation techniques can help minimise noise, making modern metal roofs quieter than many might expect.
For those sensitive to noise, considering these factors during installation can make a significant difference.
Resale Value and Market Perception
The impact of your roofing choice on resale value and market perception is substantial. Homes with metal roofs often attract higher offers due to their durability and modern aesthetics. Homeowners may recover up to 60% of the installation cost of a metal roof when selling their home. In certain markets, a new roof can significantly enhance curb appeal, which is crucial for attracting potential buyers.
While shingle roofs can also enhance a home’s appeal, they typically do not increase resale value to the same extent as metal roofs. The peace of mind that comes with a new roof, particularly one with a longer lifespan like metal, is highly valued by homebuyers. Metal roofs, with their longevity and durability, often enhance resale value more effectively than asphalt shingles.
Common Misconceptions About Metal and Shingle Roofs
There are several common misconceptions about metal and shingle roofs that need to be addressed. One prevalent myth is that metal roofs are always more expensive than shingle roofs. While the initial costs are higher, metal roofs often provide better long-term value due to their durability and low maintenance.
Another common belief is that metal roofs do not last as long as asphalt shingles, whereas metal roofs can last over 50 years compared to 20-30 years for asphalt shingles. Many people also think that metal roofs are more prone to damage, yet they actually withstand severe weather better than shingle roofs.
Concerns about noise during rain are often exaggerated, as modern metal roofing installations typically include insulation to significantly reduce sound. Finally, some homeowners believe that metal roofs require extensive maintenance, but they generally need less upkeep than shingle roofs, which can suffer from curling and moss growth. Additionally, some people worry that metal roofs noisy during storms, but this is often mitigated by proper installation.
Metal roofs can also enhance resale value due to their longevity and metal roofs durable, contrary to the misconception that metal roofs tend to not add value.
Summary
In conclusion, both metal and shingle roofing materials have their unique advantages and disadvantages. Metal roofs offer exceptional durability, energy efficiency, and a long lifespan, making them a cost-effective choice in the long run. They also have a lower environmental impact and can enhance resale value. However, their higher initial cost and complex installation process can be drawbacks for some homeowners.
On the other hand, shingle roofs are more affordable upfront and offer extensive design options, but they require more maintenance and have a shorter lifespan. The choice between metal and shingle roofing ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. By weighing the pros and cons discussed in this blog, you can make an informed decision that best suits your home and lifestyle.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the lifespan of metal roofs compared to shingle roofs?
Metal roofs significantly outlast shingle roofs, with a lifespan of 40 to 70 years compared to just 20 to 30 years for asphalt shingles. Investing in a metal roof can provide long-term durability and cost savings over time.
Are metal roofs more energy-efficient than asphalt shingles?
Yes, metal roofs are more energy-efficient than asphalt shingles, as they can reflect up to 70% of solar energy, leading to lower cooling costs.
Do metal roofs require more maintenance than shingle roofs?
Metal roofs require less maintenance than shingle roofs, as they do not suffer from problems like cracking and mold growth commonly associated with asphalt shingles.
How do metal roofs perform in extreme weather conditions?
Metal roofs excel in extreme weather, enduring winds up to 140 miles per hour and offering excellent fire resistance with a Class A rating, ensuring reliable performance during severe conditions.
What are the common misconceptions about metal roofs?
A common misconception is that metal roofs are always more expensive and noisier; however, they often provide long-term savings, are quieter with proper installation, and require less maintenance than traditional shingles. Embracing the truth about metal roofs can lead to more informed choices for your roofing needs.
